Grade Retention and Social Promotion Dichotomy: A Theoretical and Conceptual Analysis

Jeanette Jacobs(1), Oktavian Mantiri(2),

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46843/jiecr.v3i2.93


(1) Universitas Klabat, Indonesia
(2) Universitas Klabat, Indonesia

Abstract

The dichotomy of retention versus promotion in education is persistent. It is a high stake decision teachers, administrators, and policymakers have to make. This article critically reviewed the die-hard retention factors and looked at alternative ways to deal with them. It emphasizes that the approach to repeating grades cannot be taken frivolously. Teachers, administrators, and policy makers' decisions will not only have life-long effects for the individuals upon whom they are placed, but they will undoubtedly affect the future societies as a whole. This article suggested that both teachers and administrators have the vital and deciding power to elect which approach to take, contextualizing curricula and professional development training sensitive to grade retention issues. Educational administrators and teachers must have the insight to recognize the failures and the courage to accept new ways to deal with old problems.

Keywords

at-risk students; failing students; grade retention; progress monitoring; social promotion

Full Text:

PDF

References

Adnan, M., Habib, A., Ashraf, J., Mussadiq, S., Raza, A. A., Abid, M., Bashir, M., & Khan, S. U. (2021). Predicting at-Risk Students at Different Percentages of Course Length for Early Intervention Using Machine Learning Models. IEEE Access, 9, 7519–7539. https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2021.3049446

Berlin, A. (2008). Retention & Social Promotion. Edweek. https://www.edweek.org/leadership/opinion-social-promotion-or-retention/2008/10

Bonvin, P., Bless, G., & Schuepbach, M. (2008). Grade retention: Decision-making and effects on learning as well as social and emotional development. School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 19(1), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/09243450701856499

Bowman, L. J. (2005). Grade Retention: Is It a Help or Hindrance to Student Academic Success? Preventing School Failure: Alternative Education for Children and Youth, 49(3), 42–46. https://doi.org/10.3200/psfl.49.3.42-46

Cabrera-Hernandez, F. (2021). Leave them kids alone! The effects of abolishing grade repetition: evidence from a nationwide reform. Education Economics. https://doi.org/10.1080/09645292.2021.1978938

Cockx, B., Picchio, M., & Baert, S. (2019). Modeling the effects of grade retention in high school. Journal of Applied Econometrics. https://doi.org/10.1002/jae.2670

Dewar, A., Hope, D., Jaap, A., & Cameron, H. (2021). Predicting failure before it happens: A 5-year, 1042 participant prospective study. Medical Teacher, 43(9), 1039–1043. https://doi.org/10.1080/0142159X.2021.1908526

Eren, O., Lovenheim, M. F., & Mocan, H. N. (2020). The Effect of Grade Retention on Adult Crime: Evidence from a Test-Based Promotion Policy. www.iza.org

Eyasu, N. (2017). Causes of Grade Nine Students’ Grade Retention in General Secondary Schools of Dabat Woreda in North Gondar, Ethiopia. International Journal of Education and Literacy Studies. https://doi.org/10.7575/aiac.ijels.v.5n.2p.84

Feathers, C. A. (2020). Teacher and administrator beliefs about grade retention in Northeast Tennessee school districts. In Electronic Theses and Dissertations (Vol. 3704). https://dc.etsu.edu/etd

Fruehwirth, J. C., Navarro, S., & Takahashi, Y. (2016). How the timing of grade retention affects outcomes: Identification and estimation of time-varying treatment effects. Journal of Labor Economics. https://doi.org/10.1086/686262

González-Betancor, S. M., & López-Puig, A. J. (2016). Grade retention in primary education is associated with quarter of birth and socioeconomic status. PLoS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0166431

Goos, M., Pipa, J., & Peixoto, F. (2021). Effectiveness of grade retention: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Educational Research Review, 34, 100401. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.EDUREV.2021.100401

Harrington-Lueker, D. (1998). Retention vs. Social Promotion. The School Administrator, 6. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ570130

Hughes, J. N., Cao, Q., West, S. G., Allee Smith, P., & Cerda, C. (2017). Effect of retention in elementary grades on dropping out of school early. Journal of School Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsp.2017.06.003

Hughes, J. N., West, S. G., Kim, H., & Bauer, S. S. (2018). Effect of early grade retention on school completion: A prospective study. Journal of Educational Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000243

Jeffers, S. J. (1987). Feel The Fear And Do It Anyway: How to Turn Your Fear and Indecision into Confidence and Action. https://www.amazon.com/Feel-Fear-Anyway®-techniques-Indecision-ebook/dp/B008OXEROK

Jimerson, S. R. (2001). Meta-analysis of grade retention research: Implications for practice in the 21st century. School Psychology Review, 30(3), 420–437.

Jimerson, S. R., Pletcher, S. M. W., Graydon, K., Schnurr, B. L., Nickerson, A. B., & Kundert, D. K. (2006). Beyond grade retention and social promotion: Promoting the social and academic competence of students. Psychology in the Schools, 43(1), 85–97. https://doi.org/10.1002/pits.20132

Leslie, P., & Lundblom, E. (2020). Specifications Grading: What It Is, and Lessons Learned. Seminars in Speech and Language, 41(4), 298–309. https://doi.org/10.1055/S-0040-1713781

Levin, B. (2007). The Failure of Failure. Phi Delta Kappan, 89(3), 234–235. https://doi.org/10.1177/003172170708900316

Lyubansky, M. (2021). How to Keep Your Restorative Justice Program from Failing. ASCD, 39–44.

Marley-Payne, J. (2021). Rethinking Nature and Nurture in Education. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 55(1), 143–166. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9752.12527

Martínez, B., & Vandegrift, J. (1991). Failing Students-Is It Worth the Cost? Undefined.

Martorell, P., & Mariano, L. T. (2018). The Causal Effects of Grade Retention on Behavioral Outcomes. Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness. https://doi.org/10.1080/19345747.2017.1390024

Mellard, D. (2004). Understanding responsiveness to intervention in learning disabilities determination. 1, 2005. https://www.wrightslaw.com/info/rti.sld.mellard.pdf

Mesler, R. M. D., Corbin, C. M., & Martin, B. H. (2021). Teacher mindset is associated with development of students’ growth mindset. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 76. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.APPDEV.2021.101299

Owings, W. A., & Magliaro, S. (1998). Grade retention: A history of failure. In Educational Leadership (Vol. 56, Issue 1, pp. 86–88). https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ570163

Parker, D. R. (2001). Social Promotion or Retention? Two Wrongs Don’t Make a Right. Leadership. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ624729

Pearson, J. (2018). Grade retention: Knowledge and attitudes of teacher educators and preservice teachers. In Moorhead Dissertations, Theses, and Projects (Vol. 45). https://red.mnstate.edu/thesis

Petrilli, M. J. (2020). What About Next Year? There’s a strong case for having many students, especially those from poor families, repeat the school year the pandemic has cost them. If done well, this could be a gift of extra time. Hoover Digest, 3, 116–119.

Pollock, J. E., & Tolone, L. J. (2021). Improving Student Learning One Teacher at a Time. In ASCD (Second). ASCD.

Romey, W. (2000). A Note on Social Promotion. Phi Delta Kappan, 81(8), 632. https://www.jstor.org/stable/20439741?refreqid=excelsior%3A4dfd5c213d093a7d343a3ae083f2338c

Silberglitt, B., Jimerson, S. R., Burns, M. K., & Appleton, J. J. (2006). Does the timing of grade retention make a difference? Examining the effects of early versus later retention. School Psychology Review, 35(1), 134–141. https://experts.umn.edu/en/publications/does-the-timing-of-grade-retention-make-a-difference-examining-th

Soler, S. C. G., González, J. C., & Alvarado, L. K. A. (2021). Should students repeat a school year? The case of grade 9 students in Colombia. International Journal of Educational Research, 110, 101886.

Van Canegem, T., Van Houtte, M., & Demanet, J. (2021). Grade retention and academic self-concept: A multilevel analysis of the effects of schools’ retention composition. British Educational Research Journal, 47(5), 1340–1360. https://doi.org/10.1002/BERJ.3729

Vandecandelaere, M., Vansteelandt, S., De Fraine, B., & Van Damme, J. (2016). The effects of early grade retention: Effect modification by prior achievement and age. Journal of School Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsp.2015.10.004

Wicaksono, T. Y., & Witoelar, F. (2019). Early Experience and Later Outcomes of Education: Schooling Transition Evidence from Indonesia. Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, 55(1), 29–60. https://doi.org/10.1080/00074918.2018.1439156

Witmer, S. M., Hoffman, L. M., & Nottis, K. E. (2004). Elementary Teachers’ Beliefs and Knowledge about Grade Retention: How Do We Know What They Know? Education, 125, 173. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ698717

Young, K. R., Schaffer, H. E., James, J. B., & Gallardo-Williams, M. T. (2020). Tired of Failing Students? Improving Student Learning Using Detailed and Automated Individualized Feedback in a Large Introductory Science Course. Innovative Higher Education 2020 46:2, 46(2), 133–151. https://doi.org/10.1007/S10755-020-09527-5

Young, S., Trujillo, N. P., Bruce, M. A., Pollard, T., Jones, J., & Range, B. (2019). Preservice teachers’ views About grade retention as an intervention for struggling students. Preventing School Failure, 63(2), 113–120. https://doi.org/10.1080/1045988X.2018.1523124

Zhang, S., & Huang, A. (2022). The Long-Term Effects of Automatic Grade Promotion on Child Development. https://ssrn.com/abstract=4021998

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


View My Stats